A proposal for a Swiss-draw style tournament system using paired comparison for rank estimation

Kazuhiro Umemura, Yasushi Nagata

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    Many sports, such as gymnastics and figure skating, can be classified as scoring competitions or as interpersonal competitions, such as soccer and baseball. Moreover, round robin tournaments and elimination tournaments are used prominently in tournament systems to rank participants in interpersonal competitions. In a round robin tournament, establishing an order for participant play is simple, but each player must be matched against all other players. Consequently, much time is required to complete a round robin tournament. On the other hand, when using an elimination tournament, it is possible to rank the top competitors by playing fewer games, although it is difficult to identify where participants who lose games fit in the final order. To compensate for these disadvantages, cyclic designs and Swiss system tournaments have been proposed recently. In this study, we propose a new tournament system that utilizes a paired-competition methodology, which is based on the concepts of cyclic designs and Swiss system tournament. Our aim is to eliminate the disadvantages of round robin and elimination tournaments. To this end, we simulate the tournament system proposed, doing so under various conditions. We are able to demonstrate the superiority of this system over conventional tournament systems by comparing the accuracy of the estimated rank order of each tournament system, as well as the number of games required to complete each tournament system.

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)21-32
    Number of pages12
    JournalJournal of Japan Industrial Management Association
    Volume69
    Issue number1
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2018 Jan 1

    Fingerprint

    Rank Estimation
    Paired Comparisons
    Tournament
    Sports
    Cyclic Design
    Elimination
    Game
    Style
    Paired comparisons
    Rank order

    Keywords

    • Cyclic designs
    • Paired comparison
    • Ranking system
    • Swiss system tournament

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Strategy and Management
    • Management Science and Operations Research
    • Industrial and Manufacturing Engineering
    • Applied Mathematics

    Cite this

    A proposal for a Swiss-draw style tournament system using paired comparison for rank estimation. / Umemura, Kazuhiro; Nagata, Yasushi.

    In: Journal of Japan Industrial Management Association, Vol. 69, No. 1, 01.01.2018, p. 21-32.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    @article{e95b1af14ce543e5adc24e33ef2bf8ac,
    title = "A proposal for a Swiss-draw style tournament system using paired comparison for rank estimation",
    abstract = "Many sports, such as gymnastics and figure skating, can be classified as scoring competitions or as interpersonal competitions, such as soccer and baseball. Moreover, round robin tournaments and elimination tournaments are used prominently in tournament systems to rank participants in interpersonal competitions. In a round robin tournament, establishing an order for participant play is simple, but each player must be matched against all other players. Consequently, much time is required to complete a round robin tournament. On the other hand, when using an elimination tournament, it is possible to rank the top competitors by playing fewer games, although it is difficult to identify where participants who lose games fit in the final order. To compensate for these disadvantages, cyclic designs and Swiss system tournaments have been proposed recently. In this study, we propose a new tournament system that utilizes a paired-competition methodology, which is based on the concepts of cyclic designs and Swiss system tournament. Our aim is to eliminate the disadvantages of round robin and elimination tournaments. To this end, we simulate the tournament system proposed, doing so under various conditions. We are able to demonstrate the superiority of this system over conventional tournament systems by comparing the accuracy of the estimated rank order of each tournament system, as well as the number of games required to complete each tournament system.",
    keywords = "Cyclic designs, Paired comparison, Ranking system, Swiss system tournament",
    author = "Kazuhiro Umemura and Yasushi Nagata",
    year = "2018",
    month = "1",
    day = "1",
    doi = "10.11221/jima.69.21",
    language = "English",
    volume = "69",
    pages = "21--32",
    journal = "Journal of Japan Industrial Management Association",
    issn = "0386-4812",
    publisher = "Nihon Keikei Kogakkai",
    number = "1",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - A proposal for a Swiss-draw style tournament system using paired comparison for rank estimation

    AU - Umemura, Kazuhiro

    AU - Nagata, Yasushi

    PY - 2018/1/1

    Y1 - 2018/1/1

    N2 - Many sports, such as gymnastics and figure skating, can be classified as scoring competitions or as interpersonal competitions, such as soccer and baseball. Moreover, round robin tournaments and elimination tournaments are used prominently in tournament systems to rank participants in interpersonal competitions. In a round robin tournament, establishing an order for participant play is simple, but each player must be matched against all other players. Consequently, much time is required to complete a round robin tournament. On the other hand, when using an elimination tournament, it is possible to rank the top competitors by playing fewer games, although it is difficult to identify where participants who lose games fit in the final order. To compensate for these disadvantages, cyclic designs and Swiss system tournaments have been proposed recently. In this study, we propose a new tournament system that utilizes a paired-competition methodology, which is based on the concepts of cyclic designs and Swiss system tournament. Our aim is to eliminate the disadvantages of round robin and elimination tournaments. To this end, we simulate the tournament system proposed, doing so under various conditions. We are able to demonstrate the superiority of this system over conventional tournament systems by comparing the accuracy of the estimated rank order of each tournament system, as well as the number of games required to complete each tournament system.

    AB - Many sports, such as gymnastics and figure skating, can be classified as scoring competitions or as interpersonal competitions, such as soccer and baseball. Moreover, round robin tournaments and elimination tournaments are used prominently in tournament systems to rank participants in interpersonal competitions. In a round robin tournament, establishing an order for participant play is simple, but each player must be matched against all other players. Consequently, much time is required to complete a round robin tournament. On the other hand, when using an elimination tournament, it is possible to rank the top competitors by playing fewer games, although it is difficult to identify where participants who lose games fit in the final order. To compensate for these disadvantages, cyclic designs and Swiss system tournaments have been proposed recently. In this study, we propose a new tournament system that utilizes a paired-competition methodology, which is based on the concepts of cyclic designs and Swiss system tournament. Our aim is to eliminate the disadvantages of round robin and elimination tournaments. To this end, we simulate the tournament system proposed, doing so under various conditions. We are able to demonstrate the superiority of this system over conventional tournament systems by comparing the accuracy of the estimated rank order of each tournament system, as well as the number of games required to complete each tournament system.

    KW - Cyclic designs

    KW - Paired comparison

    KW - Ranking system

    KW - Swiss system tournament

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85047124261&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85047124261&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.11221/jima.69.21

    DO - 10.11221/jima.69.21

    M3 - Article

    VL - 69

    SP - 21

    EP - 32

    JO - Journal of Japan Industrial Management Association

    JF - Journal of Japan Industrial Management Association

    SN - 0386-4812

    IS - 1

    ER -