Energy policy participation through networks transcending cleavage: An analysis of Japanese and German renewable energy promotion policies

Manuela Hartwig, Yohei Kobashi, Sae Okura, Leslie Tkach-Kawasaki

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Developed countries with minimal energy self-sufficiency struggle with lowering their dependence on oil and coal. Security guarantees countermeasures against global warming, and ensuring new energy sources are issues that have driven their choices between nuclear power generation and promotion of renewable energy resources in recent years. Individual nations such as Japan and Germany have been implementing various policies according to their own political and social circumstances, and often these circumstances include discussions and negotiations among diverse actors with different viewpoints and objectives. The networks formed by overcoming the cleavage between the electric power industry and the community consisting mainly of environmental organizations and left-wing political forces could also function as an additional means for environmental actors to break through the impasse formed by the political structure. However, in assessing the effectiveness of the ties that overcome this confrontation, in addition to the existence of ties that connect such communities, it is also necessary to consider whether the influence of environmental actors through intermediary networks extends to the policy formation process. This paper describes the networks involved in the renewable energy feed-in tariff system enacted in Japan after March 2011 and in Germany in the early 2000s and 2012 to investigate such influences. When comparing the energy policies of Japan and Germany, corresponding networks unifying the two communities in both countries were observed in an analysis that emphasizes the existence of ties. However, an in-depth analysis of attitude-based networks and hyperlink networks focusing on policy reveals the predominance of economic and industrial interests in Japan, as well as functional differences even within the same corresponding networks.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1485-1512
Number of pages28
JournalQuality and Quantity
Volume49
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2014 Sep 21
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Renewable Energy
energy policy
renewable energy
promotion
participation
Japan
Energy
Tie
electric power industry
community
Global Warming
Minimal Energy
nuclear power
self-sufficiency
energy source
political structure
Sufficiency
Countermeasures
Participation
Policy

Keywords

  • Feed-in tariff
  • Hyperlink networks
  • Network analysis
  • Policy networks
  • Renewable energy policy

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Statistics and Probability
  • Social Sciences(all)

Cite this

Energy policy participation through networks transcending cleavage : An analysis of Japanese and German renewable energy promotion policies. / Hartwig, Manuela; Kobashi, Yohei; Okura, Sae; Tkach-Kawasaki, Leslie.

In: Quality and Quantity, Vol. 49, No. 4, 21.09.2014, p. 1485-1512.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Hartwig, Manuela ; Kobashi, Yohei ; Okura, Sae ; Tkach-Kawasaki, Leslie. / Energy policy participation through networks transcending cleavage : An analysis of Japanese and German renewable energy promotion policies. In: Quality and Quantity. 2014 ; Vol. 49, No. 4. pp. 1485-1512.
@article{ef5219ce8fd54437899d39f360d8977b,
title = "Energy policy participation through networks transcending cleavage: An analysis of Japanese and German renewable energy promotion policies",
abstract = "Developed countries with minimal energy self-sufficiency struggle with lowering their dependence on oil and coal. Security guarantees countermeasures against global warming, and ensuring new energy sources are issues that have driven their choices between nuclear power generation and promotion of renewable energy resources in recent years. Individual nations such as Japan and Germany have been implementing various policies according to their own political and social circumstances, and often these circumstances include discussions and negotiations among diverse actors with different viewpoints and objectives. The networks formed by overcoming the cleavage between the electric power industry and the community consisting mainly of environmental organizations and left-wing political forces could also function as an additional means for environmental actors to break through the impasse formed by the political structure. However, in assessing the effectiveness of the ties that overcome this confrontation, in addition to the existence of ties that connect such communities, it is also necessary to consider whether the influence of environmental actors through intermediary networks extends to the policy formation process. This paper describes the networks involved in the renewable energy feed-in tariff system enacted in Japan after March 2011 and in Germany in the early 2000s and 2012 to investigate such influences. When comparing the energy policies of Japan and Germany, corresponding networks unifying the two communities in both countries were observed in an analysis that emphasizes the existence of ties. However, an in-depth analysis of attitude-based networks and hyperlink networks focusing on policy reveals the predominance of economic and industrial interests in Japan, as well as functional differences even within the same corresponding networks.",
keywords = "Feed-in tariff, Hyperlink networks, Network analysis, Policy networks, Renewable energy policy",
author = "Manuela Hartwig and Yohei Kobashi and Sae Okura and Leslie Tkach-Kawasaki",
year = "2014",
month = "9",
day = "21",
doi = "10.1007/s11135-014-0093-9",
language = "English",
volume = "49",
pages = "1485--1512",
journal = "Quality and Quantity",
issn = "0033-5177",
publisher = "Springer Netherlands",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Energy policy participation through networks transcending cleavage

T2 - An analysis of Japanese and German renewable energy promotion policies

AU - Hartwig, Manuela

AU - Kobashi, Yohei

AU - Okura, Sae

AU - Tkach-Kawasaki, Leslie

PY - 2014/9/21

Y1 - 2014/9/21

N2 - Developed countries with minimal energy self-sufficiency struggle with lowering their dependence on oil and coal. Security guarantees countermeasures against global warming, and ensuring new energy sources are issues that have driven their choices between nuclear power generation and promotion of renewable energy resources in recent years. Individual nations such as Japan and Germany have been implementing various policies according to their own political and social circumstances, and often these circumstances include discussions and negotiations among diverse actors with different viewpoints and objectives. The networks formed by overcoming the cleavage between the electric power industry and the community consisting mainly of environmental organizations and left-wing political forces could also function as an additional means for environmental actors to break through the impasse formed by the political structure. However, in assessing the effectiveness of the ties that overcome this confrontation, in addition to the existence of ties that connect such communities, it is also necessary to consider whether the influence of environmental actors through intermediary networks extends to the policy formation process. This paper describes the networks involved in the renewable energy feed-in tariff system enacted in Japan after March 2011 and in Germany in the early 2000s and 2012 to investigate such influences. When comparing the energy policies of Japan and Germany, corresponding networks unifying the two communities in both countries were observed in an analysis that emphasizes the existence of ties. However, an in-depth analysis of attitude-based networks and hyperlink networks focusing on policy reveals the predominance of economic and industrial interests in Japan, as well as functional differences even within the same corresponding networks.

AB - Developed countries with minimal energy self-sufficiency struggle with lowering their dependence on oil and coal. Security guarantees countermeasures against global warming, and ensuring new energy sources are issues that have driven their choices between nuclear power generation and promotion of renewable energy resources in recent years. Individual nations such as Japan and Germany have been implementing various policies according to their own political and social circumstances, and often these circumstances include discussions and negotiations among diverse actors with different viewpoints and objectives. The networks formed by overcoming the cleavage between the electric power industry and the community consisting mainly of environmental organizations and left-wing political forces could also function as an additional means for environmental actors to break through the impasse formed by the political structure. However, in assessing the effectiveness of the ties that overcome this confrontation, in addition to the existence of ties that connect such communities, it is also necessary to consider whether the influence of environmental actors through intermediary networks extends to the policy formation process. This paper describes the networks involved in the renewable energy feed-in tariff system enacted in Japan after March 2011 and in Germany in the early 2000s and 2012 to investigate such influences. When comparing the energy policies of Japan and Germany, corresponding networks unifying the two communities in both countries were observed in an analysis that emphasizes the existence of ties. However, an in-depth analysis of attitude-based networks and hyperlink networks focusing on policy reveals the predominance of economic and industrial interests in Japan, as well as functional differences even within the same corresponding networks.

KW - Feed-in tariff

KW - Hyperlink networks

KW - Network analysis

KW - Policy networks

KW - Renewable energy policy

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84930763123&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84930763123&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s11135-014-0093-9

DO - 10.1007/s11135-014-0093-9

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84930763123

VL - 49

SP - 1485

EP - 1512

JO - Quality and Quantity

JF - Quality and Quantity

SN - 0033-5177

IS - 4

ER -