Gramsci’s critique of Croce on the Catholic Church

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Antonio Gramsci rigorously analysed the modern transformation of the Catholic Church and its strategy to spread its worldview to the Italian masses through secular means. His critique of the Church largely drew on his examination of the grounds that ensured Croce’s critique was doomed to failure. Despite its harshness, Croce’s critique failed because he did not grasp that the main target of the Church’s strategy was the common sense of the masses, while Croce pursued his critique in a highly idealist manner, appealing only to his fellow intellectuals. He thereby, according to Gramsci, helped to reinforce the Church’s strategy by endorsing the rigid separation between the intellectuals and the masses. In contrast, unlike Croce and orthodox Marxism, Gramsci did not dismiss religion as a mere absurdity, recognising it as a source of people’s common sense that, albeit confusing in nature, informed their worldview. Gramsci considered that even the common sense of the masses constituted an appropriate grasp of the world, or ‘good sense’. In this sense, Gramsci’s critique of religion echoed his preoccupation with the longstanding division of Italian society between the intellectuals and the masses, which prevented mass participation in politics.

Original languageEnglish
JournalHistory of European Ideas
DOIs
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 2019 Jan 1

Fingerprint

church
intellectual
worldview
Religion
Marxism
Antonio Gramsci
Catholic Church
examination
participation
politics
Common Sense
World View

Keywords

  • Catholicism
  • common sense
  • Croce
  • Gramsci
  • religion
  • superstructure

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • History
  • Sociology and Political Science
  • Philosophy

Cite this

Gramsci’s critique of Croce on the Catholic Church. / Chino, Takahiro.

In: History of European Ideas, 01.01.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{3c75ff247a9c454d8210e350343f3dba,
title = "Gramsci’s critique of Croce on the Catholic Church",
abstract = "Antonio Gramsci rigorously analysed the modern transformation of the Catholic Church and its strategy to spread its worldview to the Italian masses through secular means. His critique of the Church largely drew on his examination of the grounds that ensured Croce’s critique was doomed to failure. Despite its harshness, Croce’s critique failed because he did not grasp that the main target of the Church’s strategy was the common sense of the masses, while Croce pursued his critique in a highly idealist manner, appealing only to his fellow intellectuals. He thereby, according to Gramsci, helped to reinforce the Church’s strategy by endorsing the rigid separation between the intellectuals and the masses. In contrast, unlike Croce and orthodox Marxism, Gramsci did not dismiss religion as a mere absurdity, recognising it as a source of people’s common sense that, albeit confusing in nature, informed their worldview. Gramsci considered that even the common sense of the masses constituted an appropriate grasp of the world, or ‘good sense’. In this sense, Gramsci’s critique of religion echoed his preoccupation with the longstanding division of Italian society between the intellectuals and the masses, which prevented mass participation in politics.",
keywords = "Catholicism, common sense, Croce, Gramsci, religion, superstructure",
author = "Takahiro Chino",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1080/01916599.2019.1653352",
language = "English",
journal = "History of European Ideas",
issn = "0191-6599",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Gramsci’s critique of Croce on the Catholic Church

AU - Chino, Takahiro

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - Antonio Gramsci rigorously analysed the modern transformation of the Catholic Church and its strategy to spread its worldview to the Italian masses through secular means. His critique of the Church largely drew on his examination of the grounds that ensured Croce’s critique was doomed to failure. Despite its harshness, Croce’s critique failed because he did not grasp that the main target of the Church’s strategy was the common sense of the masses, while Croce pursued his critique in a highly idealist manner, appealing only to his fellow intellectuals. He thereby, according to Gramsci, helped to reinforce the Church’s strategy by endorsing the rigid separation between the intellectuals and the masses. In contrast, unlike Croce and orthodox Marxism, Gramsci did not dismiss religion as a mere absurdity, recognising it as a source of people’s common sense that, albeit confusing in nature, informed their worldview. Gramsci considered that even the common sense of the masses constituted an appropriate grasp of the world, or ‘good sense’. In this sense, Gramsci’s critique of religion echoed his preoccupation with the longstanding division of Italian society between the intellectuals and the masses, which prevented mass participation in politics.

AB - Antonio Gramsci rigorously analysed the modern transformation of the Catholic Church and its strategy to spread its worldview to the Italian masses through secular means. His critique of the Church largely drew on his examination of the grounds that ensured Croce’s critique was doomed to failure. Despite its harshness, Croce’s critique failed because he did not grasp that the main target of the Church’s strategy was the common sense of the masses, while Croce pursued his critique in a highly idealist manner, appealing only to his fellow intellectuals. He thereby, according to Gramsci, helped to reinforce the Church’s strategy by endorsing the rigid separation between the intellectuals and the masses. In contrast, unlike Croce and orthodox Marxism, Gramsci did not dismiss religion as a mere absurdity, recognising it as a source of people’s common sense that, albeit confusing in nature, informed their worldview. Gramsci considered that even the common sense of the masses constituted an appropriate grasp of the world, or ‘good sense’. In this sense, Gramsci’s critique of religion echoed his preoccupation with the longstanding division of Italian society between the intellectuals and the masses, which prevented mass participation in politics.

KW - Catholicism

KW - common sense

KW - Croce

KW - Gramsci

KW - religion

KW - superstructure

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85070836627&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85070836627&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/01916599.2019.1653352

DO - 10.1080/01916599.2019.1653352

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85070836627

JO - History of European Ideas

JF - History of European Ideas

SN - 0191-6599

ER -