How can we use counter evidence effectively in order to rectify learners' misconceptions? Effectiveness of the "unified method"

Toshihiko Shindo, Keiichi Magara, Yohji Fushimi

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Two types of teaching methods for rectifying learners' misconceptions have been proposed. They vary in whether counter evidence is or is not utilized. However, because both methods have weak points, we propose, in the present study, a "unified method," that is, a new method that unifies the 2 previous methods. With the unified method, learners are first presented a problem that they could not solve correctly because of some misconception ; they then are presented another similar problem that they can solve correctly. On the basis of that correct response, they are led to find the correct rule for solving the problem, and are also encouraged to apply the rule to a series of similar problems. The present study compares the effectiveness of the unified method and the 2 previous methods for rectifying learners' misconceptions. Undergraduates (N = 76), most of whom had the misconception that vacuums draw substances into them, were allocated to 1 of 3 groups. The unified method had better results than the 2 other methods in the following respects : (1) it rectified the learners' misconceptions most effectively, (2) it made the learners aware that their previous knowledge (i.e., their misconception) had been replaced by a correct idea, and (3) it aroused their interest.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)162-173
Number of pages12
JournalJapanese Journal of Educational Psychology
Volume54
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 2006 Jun

Fingerprint

evidence
organization of teaching
Vacuum
teaching method
Teaching
Group

Keywords

  • Conceptual change
  • Misconceptions
  • Teaching strategy
  • Undergraduates
  • Unified method

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Psychology(all)
  • Developmental and Educational Psychology

Cite this

How can we use counter evidence effectively in order to rectify learners' misconceptions? Effectiveness of the "unified method". / Shindo, Toshihiko; Magara, Keiichi; Fushimi, Yohji.

In: Japanese Journal of Educational Psychology, Vol. 54, No. 2, 06.2006, p. 162-173.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{55efdf3fe537468f9c1e62b91a8cc708,
title = "How can we use counter evidence effectively in order to rectify learners' misconceptions? Effectiveness of the {"}unified method{"}",
abstract = "Two types of teaching methods for rectifying learners' misconceptions have been proposed. They vary in whether counter evidence is or is not utilized. However, because both methods have weak points, we propose, in the present study, a {"}unified method,{"} that is, a new method that unifies the 2 previous methods. With the unified method, learners are first presented a problem that they could not solve correctly because of some misconception ; they then are presented another similar problem that they can solve correctly. On the basis of that correct response, they are led to find the correct rule for solving the problem, and are also encouraged to apply the rule to a series of similar problems. The present study compares the effectiveness of the unified method and the 2 previous methods for rectifying learners' misconceptions. Undergraduates (N = 76), most of whom had the misconception that vacuums draw substances into them, were allocated to 1 of 3 groups. The unified method had better results than the 2 other methods in the following respects : (1) it rectified the learners' misconceptions most effectively, (2) it made the learners aware that their previous knowledge (i.e., their misconception) had been replaced by a correct idea, and (3) it aroused their interest.",
keywords = "Conceptual change, Misconceptions, Teaching strategy, Undergraduates, Unified method",
author = "Toshihiko Shindo and Keiichi Magara and Yohji Fushimi",
year = "2006",
month = "6",
language = "English",
volume = "54",
pages = "162--173",
journal = "Japanese Journal of Educational Psychology",
issn = "0021-5015",
publisher = "Japanese Association of Educational Psychology",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - How can we use counter evidence effectively in order to rectify learners' misconceptions? Effectiveness of the "unified method"

AU - Shindo, Toshihiko

AU - Magara, Keiichi

AU - Fushimi, Yohji

PY - 2006/6

Y1 - 2006/6

N2 - Two types of teaching methods for rectifying learners' misconceptions have been proposed. They vary in whether counter evidence is or is not utilized. However, because both methods have weak points, we propose, in the present study, a "unified method," that is, a new method that unifies the 2 previous methods. With the unified method, learners are first presented a problem that they could not solve correctly because of some misconception ; they then are presented another similar problem that they can solve correctly. On the basis of that correct response, they are led to find the correct rule for solving the problem, and are also encouraged to apply the rule to a series of similar problems. The present study compares the effectiveness of the unified method and the 2 previous methods for rectifying learners' misconceptions. Undergraduates (N = 76), most of whom had the misconception that vacuums draw substances into them, were allocated to 1 of 3 groups. The unified method had better results than the 2 other methods in the following respects : (1) it rectified the learners' misconceptions most effectively, (2) it made the learners aware that their previous knowledge (i.e., their misconception) had been replaced by a correct idea, and (3) it aroused their interest.

AB - Two types of teaching methods for rectifying learners' misconceptions have been proposed. They vary in whether counter evidence is or is not utilized. However, because both methods have weak points, we propose, in the present study, a "unified method," that is, a new method that unifies the 2 previous methods. With the unified method, learners are first presented a problem that they could not solve correctly because of some misconception ; they then are presented another similar problem that they can solve correctly. On the basis of that correct response, they are led to find the correct rule for solving the problem, and are also encouraged to apply the rule to a series of similar problems. The present study compares the effectiveness of the unified method and the 2 previous methods for rectifying learners' misconceptions. Undergraduates (N = 76), most of whom had the misconception that vacuums draw substances into them, were allocated to 1 of 3 groups. The unified method had better results than the 2 other methods in the following respects : (1) it rectified the learners' misconceptions most effectively, (2) it made the learners aware that their previous knowledge (i.e., their misconception) had been replaced by a correct idea, and (3) it aroused their interest.

KW - Conceptual change

KW - Misconceptions

KW - Teaching strategy

KW - Undergraduates

KW - Unified method

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33749174933&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33749174933&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 54

SP - 162

EP - 173

JO - Japanese Journal of Educational Psychology

JF - Japanese Journal of Educational Psychology

SN - 0021-5015

IS - 2

ER -