Myelin Measurement

Comparison between Simultaneous Tissue Relaxometry, Magnetization Transfer Saturation Index, and T1w/T2w Ratio Methods

Akifumi Hagiwara, Masaaki Hori, Koji Kamagata, Marcel Warntjes, Daisuke Matsuyoshi, Misaki Nakazawa, Ryo Ueda, Christina Andica, Saori Koshino, Tomoko Maekawa, Ryusuke Irie, Tomohiro Takamura, Kanako Kunishima Kumamaru, Osamu Abe, Shigeki Aoki

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

8 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Magnetization transfer (MT) imaging has been widely used for estimating myelin content in the brain. Recently, two other approaches, namely simultaneous tissue relaxometry of R1 and R2 relaxation rates and proton density (SyMRI) and the ratio of T1-weighted to T2-weighted images (T1w/T2w ratio), were also proposed as methods for measuring myelin. SyMRI and MT imaging have been reported to correlate well with actual myelin by histology. However, for T1w/T2w ratio, such evidence is limited. In 20 healthy adults, we examined the correlation between these three methods, using MT saturation index (MTsat) for MT imaging. After calibration, white matter (WM) to gray matter (GM) contrast was the highest for SyMRI among these three metrics. Even though SyMRI and MTsat showed strong correlation in the WM (r = 0.72), only weak correlation was found between T1w/T2w and SyMRI (r = 0.45) or MTsat (r = 0.38) (correlation coefficients significantly different from each other, with p values < 0.001). In subcortical and cortical GM, these measurements showed moderate to strong correlations to each other (r = 0.54 to 0.78). In conclusion, the high correlation between SyMRI and MTsat indicates that both methods are similarly suited to measure myelin in the WM, whereas T1w/T2w ratio may be less optimal.

Original languageEnglish
Article number10554
JournalScientific Reports
Volume8
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2018 Dec 1

Fingerprint

Myelin Sheath
Calibration
Protons
Histology
Brain
White Matter
Gray Matter

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • General

Cite this

Myelin Measurement : Comparison between Simultaneous Tissue Relaxometry, Magnetization Transfer Saturation Index, and T1w/T2w Ratio Methods. / Hagiwara, Akifumi; Hori, Masaaki; Kamagata, Koji; Warntjes, Marcel; Matsuyoshi, Daisuke; Nakazawa, Misaki; Ueda, Ryo; Andica, Christina; Koshino, Saori; Maekawa, Tomoko; Irie, Ryusuke; Takamura, Tomohiro; Kumamaru, Kanako Kunishima; Abe, Osamu; Aoki, Shigeki.

In: Scientific Reports, Vol. 8, No. 1, 10554, 01.12.2018.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Hagiwara, A, Hori, M, Kamagata, K, Warntjes, M, Matsuyoshi, D, Nakazawa, M, Ueda, R, Andica, C, Koshino, S, Maekawa, T, Irie, R, Takamura, T, Kumamaru, KK, Abe, O & Aoki, S 2018, 'Myelin Measurement: Comparison between Simultaneous Tissue Relaxometry, Magnetization Transfer Saturation Index, and T1w/T2w Ratio Methods', Scientific Reports, vol. 8, no. 1, 10554. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-28852-6
Hagiwara, Akifumi ; Hori, Masaaki ; Kamagata, Koji ; Warntjes, Marcel ; Matsuyoshi, Daisuke ; Nakazawa, Misaki ; Ueda, Ryo ; Andica, Christina ; Koshino, Saori ; Maekawa, Tomoko ; Irie, Ryusuke ; Takamura, Tomohiro ; Kumamaru, Kanako Kunishima ; Abe, Osamu ; Aoki, Shigeki. / Myelin Measurement : Comparison between Simultaneous Tissue Relaxometry, Magnetization Transfer Saturation Index, and T1w/T2w Ratio Methods. In: Scientific Reports. 2018 ; Vol. 8, No. 1.
@article{2cbf50bf106245c4a3097072d5e7ec0e,
title = "Myelin Measurement: Comparison between Simultaneous Tissue Relaxometry, Magnetization Transfer Saturation Index, and T1w/T2w Ratio Methods",
abstract = "Magnetization transfer (MT) imaging has been widely used for estimating myelin content in the brain. Recently, two other approaches, namely simultaneous tissue relaxometry of R1 and R2 relaxation rates and proton density (SyMRI) and the ratio of T1-weighted to T2-weighted images (T1w/T2w ratio), were also proposed as methods for measuring myelin. SyMRI and MT imaging have been reported to correlate well with actual myelin by histology. However, for T1w/T2w ratio, such evidence is limited. In 20 healthy adults, we examined the correlation between these three methods, using MT saturation index (MTsat) for MT imaging. After calibration, white matter (WM) to gray matter (GM) contrast was the highest for SyMRI among these three metrics. Even though SyMRI and MTsat showed strong correlation in the WM (r = 0.72), only weak correlation was found between T1w/T2w and SyMRI (r = 0.45) or MTsat (r = 0.38) (correlation coefficients significantly different from each other, with p values < 0.001). In subcortical and cortical GM, these measurements showed moderate to strong correlations to each other (r = 0.54 to 0.78). In conclusion, the high correlation between SyMRI and MTsat indicates that both methods are similarly suited to measure myelin in the WM, whereas T1w/T2w ratio may be less optimal.",
author = "Akifumi Hagiwara and Masaaki Hori and Koji Kamagata and Marcel Warntjes and Daisuke Matsuyoshi and Misaki Nakazawa and Ryo Ueda and Christina Andica and Saori Koshino and Tomoko Maekawa and Ryusuke Irie and Tomohiro Takamura and Kumamaru, {Kanako Kunishima} and Osamu Abe and Shigeki Aoki",
year = "2018",
month = "12",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1038/s41598-018-28852-6",
language = "English",
volume = "8",
journal = "Scientific Reports",
issn = "2045-2322",
publisher = "Nature Publishing Group",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Myelin Measurement

T2 - Comparison between Simultaneous Tissue Relaxometry, Magnetization Transfer Saturation Index, and T1w/T2w Ratio Methods

AU - Hagiwara, Akifumi

AU - Hori, Masaaki

AU - Kamagata, Koji

AU - Warntjes, Marcel

AU - Matsuyoshi, Daisuke

AU - Nakazawa, Misaki

AU - Ueda, Ryo

AU - Andica, Christina

AU - Koshino, Saori

AU - Maekawa, Tomoko

AU - Irie, Ryusuke

AU - Takamura, Tomohiro

AU - Kumamaru, Kanako Kunishima

AU - Abe, Osamu

AU - Aoki, Shigeki

PY - 2018/12/1

Y1 - 2018/12/1

N2 - Magnetization transfer (MT) imaging has been widely used for estimating myelin content in the brain. Recently, two other approaches, namely simultaneous tissue relaxometry of R1 and R2 relaxation rates and proton density (SyMRI) and the ratio of T1-weighted to T2-weighted images (T1w/T2w ratio), were also proposed as methods for measuring myelin. SyMRI and MT imaging have been reported to correlate well with actual myelin by histology. However, for T1w/T2w ratio, such evidence is limited. In 20 healthy adults, we examined the correlation between these three methods, using MT saturation index (MTsat) for MT imaging. After calibration, white matter (WM) to gray matter (GM) contrast was the highest for SyMRI among these three metrics. Even though SyMRI and MTsat showed strong correlation in the WM (r = 0.72), only weak correlation was found between T1w/T2w and SyMRI (r = 0.45) or MTsat (r = 0.38) (correlation coefficients significantly different from each other, with p values < 0.001). In subcortical and cortical GM, these measurements showed moderate to strong correlations to each other (r = 0.54 to 0.78). In conclusion, the high correlation between SyMRI and MTsat indicates that both methods are similarly suited to measure myelin in the WM, whereas T1w/T2w ratio may be less optimal.

AB - Magnetization transfer (MT) imaging has been widely used for estimating myelin content in the brain. Recently, two other approaches, namely simultaneous tissue relaxometry of R1 and R2 relaxation rates and proton density (SyMRI) and the ratio of T1-weighted to T2-weighted images (T1w/T2w ratio), were also proposed as methods for measuring myelin. SyMRI and MT imaging have been reported to correlate well with actual myelin by histology. However, for T1w/T2w ratio, such evidence is limited. In 20 healthy adults, we examined the correlation between these three methods, using MT saturation index (MTsat) for MT imaging. After calibration, white matter (WM) to gray matter (GM) contrast was the highest for SyMRI among these three metrics. Even though SyMRI and MTsat showed strong correlation in the WM (r = 0.72), only weak correlation was found between T1w/T2w and SyMRI (r = 0.45) or MTsat (r = 0.38) (correlation coefficients significantly different from each other, with p values < 0.001). In subcortical and cortical GM, these measurements showed moderate to strong correlations to each other (r = 0.54 to 0.78). In conclusion, the high correlation between SyMRI and MTsat indicates that both methods are similarly suited to measure myelin in the WM, whereas T1w/T2w ratio may be less optimal.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85049902091&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85049902091&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1038/s41598-018-28852-6

DO - 10.1038/s41598-018-28852-6

M3 - Article

VL - 8

JO - Scientific Reports

JF - Scientific Reports

SN - 2045-2322

IS - 1

M1 - 10554

ER -