Spectral analysis of line edge and line-width roughness with long-range correlation

Atsushi Hiraiwa, Akio Nishida

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

24 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Large-scale integrations (LSIs) are facing an ever-growing problem of device variability. One of the origins that cause the variability is line-width roughness (LWR) caused by line edge roughness (LER). Accurate characterization of the LWR plays an essential role in controlling the LWR. To do this, we report a methodology, named the "assembly method," that enables to analyze LWR statistics beyond the conventional correlation length limit, basing on the previous "patchwork" method and recent discrete power spectral density (PSD) method. The methodology virtually assembles a long line by gathering line segments that are randomly scattered on a single line or equally processed different lines. The virtual lines are repeatedly assembled by randomly changing the combination of the segments and the order of the gathered segments while permitting overlaps of the segments between the assembled lines. Squared Fourier transforms of their widths are averaged over the assembled lines to obtain the PSD. By these steps, the statistical noise, which is inherent to experimental PSDs, is markedly reduced. Furthermore, to extract LWR statistics by comparing experimental and theoretical PSDs, we derived an analytic formula of the assembled-line PSD. In the derivation, the randomness of the segment collections played a key role. The PSDs calculated using the formula almost completely fitted experimental PSDs that were obtained by the assembly method. The parameters used in the best-fitted calculation revealed that the photoresist LWR of this study contained a component that had a correlation length of 2780 nm in addition to the previously reported LWR of 35 nm. The LWR variance of the component accounted for approximately 10% of the total variance. The formula also enabled us to evaluate the accuracy of experimentally obtained averages of widths. We find two distinct features in the PSDs by the assembly method. One is the oscillatory structure that shows up in the case when the correlation length is larger than half the length of the segments. A trace of this structure was actually observed in the experimental PSDs of this study. The other is the spikes that are periodically observed as a function of wave number. The spikes originate from a nonstochastic width variation that exists in all the segments in common. Their intensity is proportional to the number of gathered segments in the assembled lines. Because the spikes are excluded from the analysis, the LWR parameters determined by the assembly method are not affected by the nonstochastic variation, unlike the conventional methods. By all these results, we confirm that the assembly method of this study extends the upper limit of analyzable correlation lengths by a factor of approximately 20 and enhances the accuracy as well. This feature also has a practical significance that the widely observed LWR with a correlation length of approximately 35 nm can be analyzed by the assembly method using a conventional critical-dimension scanning-electron-microscope, without resorting to a specially designed one. Accordingly, the method will be a key tool for investigating LER and LWR in developing and manufacturing LSIs. It will also help analyze other stochastic processes in many research and development settings.

Original languageEnglish
Article number034908
JournalJournal of Applied Physics
Volume108
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2010 Aug 1
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

spectrum analysis
roughness
assembly
spikes
large scale integration
statistics
methodology
power lines
stochastic processes
research and development
photoresists
derivation
manufacturing
electron microscopes

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Physics and Astronomy(all)

Cite this

Spectral analysis of line edge and line-width roughness with long-range correlation. / Hiraiwa, Atsushi; Nishida, Akio.

In: Journal of Applied Physics, Vol. 108, No. 3, 034908, 01.08.2010.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{bb4d16a37e73478cab7f296bde3cba25,
title = "Spectral analysis of line edge and line-width roughness with long-range correlation",
abstract = "Large-scale integrations (LSIs) are facing an ever-growing problem of device variability. One of the origins that cause the variability is line-width roughness (LWR) caused by line edge roughness (LER). Accurate characterization of the LWR plays an essential role in controlling the LWR. To do this, we report a methodology, named the {"}assembly method,{"} that enables to analyze LWR statistics beyond the conventional correlation length limit, basing on the previous {"}patchwork{"} method and recent discrete power spectral density (PSD) method. The methodology virtually assembles a long line by gathering line segments that are randomly scattered on a single line or equally processed different lines. The virtual lines are repeatedly assembled by randomly changing the combination of the segments and the order of the gathered segments while permitting overlaps of the segments between the assembled lines. Squared Fourier transforms of their widths are averaged over the assembled lines to obtain the PSD. By these steps, the statistical noise, which is inherent to experimental PSDs, is markedly reduced. Furthermore, to extract LWR statistics by comparing experimental and theoretical PSDs, we derived an analytic formula of the assembled-line PSD. In the derivation, the randomness of the segment collections played a key role. The PSDs calculated using the formula almost completely fitted experimental PSDs that were obtained by the assembly method. The parameters used in the best-fitted calculation revealed that the photoresist LWR of this study contained a component that had a correlation length of 2780 nm in addition to the previously reported LWR of 35 nm. The LWR variance of the component accounted for approximately 10{\%} of the total variance. The formula also enabled us to evaluate the accuracy of experimentally obtained averages of widths. We find two distinct features in the PSDs by the assembly method. One is the oscillatory structure that shows up in the case when the correlation length is larger than half the length of the segments. A trace of this structure was actually observed in the experimental PSDs of this study. The other is the spikes that are periodically observed as a function of wave number. The spikes originate from a nonstochastic width variation that exists in all the segments in common. Their intensity is proportional to the number of gathered segments in the assembled lines. Because the spikes are excluded from the analysis, the LWR parameters determined by the assembly method are not affected by the nonstochastic variation, unlike the conventional methods. By all these results, we confirm that the assembly method of this study extends the upper limit of analyzable correlation lengths by a factor of approximately 20 and enhances the accuracy as well. This feature also has a practical significance that the widely observed LWR with a correlation length of approximately 35 nm can be analyzed by the assembly method using a conventional critical-dimension scanning-electron-microscope, without resorting to a specially designed one. Accordingly, the method will be a key tool for investigating LER and LWR in developing and manufacturing LSIs. It will also help analyze other stochastic processes in many research and development settings.",
author = "Atsushi Hiraiwa and Akio Nishida",
year = "2010",
month = "8",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1063/1.3466777",
language = "English",
volume = "108",
journal = "Journal of Applied Physics",
issn = "0021-8979",
publisher = "American Institute of Physics Publising LLC",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Spectral analysis of line edge and line-width roughness with long-range correlation

AU - Hiraiwa, Atsushi

AU - Nishida, Akio

PY - 2010/8/1

Y1 - 2010/8/1

N2 - Large-scale integrations (LSIs) are facing an ever-growing problem of device variability. One of the origins that cause the variability is line-width roughness (LWR) caused by line edge roughness (LER). Accurate characterization of the LWR plays an essential role in controlling the LWR. To do this, we report a methodology, named the "assembly method," that enables to analyze LWR statistics beyond the conventional correlation length limit, basing on the previous "patchwork" method and recent discrete power spectral density (PSD) method. The methodology virtually assembles a long line by gathering line segments that are randomly scattered on a single line or equally processed different lines. The virtual lines are repeatedly assembled by randomly changing the combination of the segments and the order of the gathered segments while permitting overlaps of the segments between the assembled lines. Squared Fourier transforms of their widths are averaged over the assembled lines to obtain the PSD. By these steps, the statistical noise, which is inherent to experimental PSDs, is markedly reduced. Furthermore, to extract LWR statistics by comparing experimental and theoretical PSDs, we derived an analytic formula of the assembled-line PSD. In the derivation, the randomness of the segment collections played a key role. The PSDs calculated using the formula almost completely fitted experimental PSDs that were obtained by the assembly method. The parameters used in the best-fitted calculation revealed that the photoresist LWR of this study contained a component that had a correlation length of 2780 nm in addition to the previously reported LWR of 35 nm. The LWR variance of the component accounted for approximately 10% of the total variance. The formula also enabled us to evaluate the accuracy of experimentally obtained averages of widths. We find two distinct features in the PSDs by the assembly method. One is the oscillatory structure that shows up in the case when the correlation length is larger than half the length of the segments. A trace of this structure was actually observed in the experimental PSDs of this study. The other is the spikes that are periodically observed as a function of wave number. The spikes originate from a nonstochastic width variation that exists in all the segments in common. Their intensity is proportional to the number of gathered segments in the assembled lines. Because the spikes are excluded from the analysis, the LWR parameters determined by the assembly method are not affected by the nonstochastic variation, unlike the conventional methods. By all these results, we confirm that the assembly method of this study extends the upper limit of analyzable correlation lengths by a factor of approximately 20 and enhances the accuracy as well. This feature also has a practical significance that the widely observed LWR with a correlation length of approximately 35 nm can be analyzed by the assembly method using a conventional critical-dimension scanning-electron-microscope, without resorting to a specially designed one. Accordingly, the method will be a key tool for investigating LER and LWR in developing and manufacturing LSIs. It will also help analyze other stochastic processes in many research and development settings.

AB - Large-scale integrations (LSIs) are facing an ever-growing problem of device variability. One of the origins that cause the variability is line-width roughness (LWR) caused by line edge roughness (LER). Accurate characterization of the LWR plays an essential role in controlling the LWR. To do this, we report a methodology, named the "assembly method," that enables to analyze LWR statistics beyond the conventional correlation length limit, basing on the previous "patchwork" method and recent discrete power spectral density (PSD) method. The methodology virtually assembles a long line by gathering line segments that are randomly scattered on a single line or equally processed different lines. The virtual lines are repeatedly assembled by randomly changing the combination of the segments and the order of the gathered segments while permitting overlaps of the segments between the assembled lines. Squared Fourier transforms of their widths are averaged over the assembled lines to obtain the PSD. By these steps, the statistical noise, which is inherent to experimental PSDs, is markedly reduced. Furthermore, to extract LWR statistics by comparing experimental and theoretical PSDs, we derived an analytic formula of the assembled-line PSD. In the derivation, the randomness of the segment collections played a key role. The PSDs calculated using the formula almost completely fitted experimental PSDs that were obtained by the assembly method. The parameters used in the best-fitted calculation revealed that the photoresist LWR of this study contained a component that had a correlation length of 2780 nm in addition to the previously reported LWR of 35 nm. The LWR variance of the component accounted for approximately 10% of the total variance. The formula also enabled us to evaluate the accuracy of experimentally obtained averages of widths. We find two distinct features in the PSDs by the assembly method. One is the oscillatory structure that shows up in the case when the correlation length is larger than half the length of the segments. A trace of this structure was actually observed in the experimental PSDs of this study. The other is the spikes that are periodically observed as a function of wave number. The spikes originate from a nonstochastic width variation that exists in all the segments in common. Their intensity is proportional to the number of gathered segments in the assembled lines. Because the spikes are excluded from the analysis, the LWR parameters determined by the assembly method are not affected by the nonstochastic variation, unlike the conventional methods. By all these results, we confirm that the assembly method of this study extends the upper limit of analyzable correlation lengths by a factor of approximately 20 and enhances the accuracy as well. This feature also has a practical significance that the widely observed LWR with a correlation length of approximately 35 nm can be analyzed by the assembly method using a conventional critical-dimension scanning-electron-microscope, without resorting to a specially designed one. Accordingly, the method will be a key tool for investigating LER and LWR in developing and manufacturing LSIs. It will also help analyze other stochastic processes in many research and development settings.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=77955878776&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=77955878776&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1063/1.3466777

DO - 10.1063/1.3466777

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:77955878776

VL - 108

JO - Journal of Applied Physics

JF - Journal of Applied Physics

SN - 0021-8979

IS - 3

M1 - 034908

ER -