Spurious “Thematic Material Effect“ On Logical Reasoning

Akira Nakagaki

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The present experiment was designed to examine so-called “thematic material effect” on logical performance in a reasoning task. In particular, the four cards problem was used to elicit preferences for various logical and illogical problem-solving strategies. The result showed that high performance in D'Andrade's “receipts task” was not due to thematic material effect but to cards shape not equivalent to that used in D'Andrade's “label factory task”, and therefore the effect was more apparent than real in the sense that the high performance was caused by illogical problem-solving strategies. Based on such evidence, “schema theory” and “viewpoint theory” purporting to explain thematic material effect were then criticized. Finally, the author proposed a new theory called “degeneration theory” and cast doubt on the idea of domain-specific knowledge.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)290-299
Number of pages10
JournalJapanese Journal of Educational Psychology
Volume35
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1987
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

performance
factory
experiment
knowledge
evidence

Keywords

  • domain specific knowledge
  • four cards problem
  • logical reasoning
  • thematic material effect
  • Wason's selection task

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Education
  • Developmental and Educational Psychology

Cite this

Spurious “Thematic Material Effect“ On Logical Reasoning. / Nakagaki, Akira.

In: Japanese Journal of Educational Psychology, Vol. 35, No. 4, 1987, p. 290-299.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{aa7c139e6900480fba5f60ed177d9316,
title = "Spurious “Thematic Material Effect“ On Logical Reasoning",
abstract = "The present experiment was designed to examine so-called “thematic material effect” on logical performance in a reasoning task. In particular, the four cards problem was used to elicit preferences for various logical and illogical problem-solving strategies. The result showed that high performance in D'Andrade's “receipts task” was not due to thematic material effect but to cards shape not equivalent to that used in D'Andrade's “label factory task”, and therefore the effect was more apparent than real in the sense that the high performance was caused by illogical problem-solving strategies. Based on such evidence, “schema theory” and “viewpoint theory” purporting to explain thematic material effect were then criticized. Finally, the author proposed a new theory called “degeneration theory” and cast doubt on the idea of domain-specific knowledge.",
keywords = "domain specific knowledge, four cards problem, logical reasoning, thematic material effect, Wason's selection task",
author = "Akira Nakagaki",
year = "1987",
doi = "10.5926/jjep1953.35.4_290",
language = "English",
volume = "35",
pages = "290--299",
journal = "Japanese Journal of Educational Psychology",
issn = "0021-5015",
publisher = "Japanese Association of Educational Psychology",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Spurious “Thematic Material Effect“ On Logical Reasoning

AU - Nakagaki, Akira

PY - 1987

Y1 - 1987

N2 - The present experiment was designed to examine so-called “thematic material effect” on logical performance in a reasoning task. In particular, the four cards problem was used to elicit preferences for various logical and illogical problem-solving strategies. The result showed that high performance in D'Andrade's “receipts task” was not due to thematic material effect but to cards shape not equivalent to that used in D'Andrade's “label factory task”, and therefore the effect was more apparent than real in the sense that the high performance was caused by illogical problem-solving strategies. Based on such evidence, “schema theory” and “viewpoint theory” purporting to explain thematic material effect were then criticized. Finally, the author proposed a new theory called “degeneration theory” and cast doubt on the idea of domain-specific knowledge.

AB - The present experiment was designed to examine so-called “thematic material effect” on logical performance in a reasoning task. In particular, the four cards problem was used to elicit preferences for various logical and illogical problem-solving strategies. The result showed that high performance in D'Andrade's “receipts task” was not due to thematic material effect but to cards shape not equivalent to that used in D'Andrade's “label factory task”, and therefore the effect was more apparent than real in the sense that the high performance was caused by illogical problem-solving strategies. Based on such evidence, “schema theory” and “viewpoint theory” purporting to explain thematic material effect were then criticized. Finally, the author proposed a new theory called “degeneration theory” and cast doubt on the idea of domain-specific knowledge.

KW - domain specific knowledge

KW - four cards problem

KW - logical reasoning

KW - thematic material effect

KW - Wason's selection task

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85008074977&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85008074977&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.5926/jjep1953.35.4_290

DO - 10.5926/jjep1953.35.4_290

M3 - Article

VL - 35

SP - 290

EP - 299

JO - Japanese Journal of Educational Psychology

JF - Japanese Journal of Educational Psychology

SN - 0021-5015

IS - 4

ER -