Standards of evidence in chronobiology: Critical review of a report that restoration of Bmal1 expression in the dorsomedial hypothalamus is sufficient to restore circadian food anticipatory rhythms in Bmal1-/- mice

Ralph E. Mistlberger, Ruud M. Buijs, Etienne Challet, Carolina Escobar, Glenn J. Landry, Andries Kalsbeek, Paul Pevet, Shigenobu Shibata

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    35 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    Daily feeding schedules generate food anticipatory rhythms of behavior and physiology that exhibit canonical properties of circadian clock control. The molecular mechanisms and location of food-entrainable circadian oscillators hypothesized to control food anticipatory rhythms are unknown. In 2008, Fuller et al reported that food-entrainable circadian rhythms are absent in mice bearing a null mutation of the circadian clock gene Bmal1 and that these rhythms can be rescued by virally-mediated restoration of Bmal1 expression in the dorsomedial nucleus of the hypothalamus (DMH) but not in the suprachiasmatic nucleus (site of the master light-entrainable circadian pacemaker). These results, taken together with controversial DMH lesion results published by the same laboratory, appear to establish the DMH as the site of a Bmal1-dependent circadian mechanism necessary and sufficient for food anticipatory rhythms. However, careful examination of the manuscript reveals numerous weaknesses in the evidence as presented. These problems are grouped as follows and elaborated in detail: 1. data management issues (apparent misalignments of plotted data), 2. failure of evidence to support the major conclusions, and 3. missing data and methodological details. The Fuller et al results are therefore considered inconclusive, and fail to clarify the role of either the DMH or Bmal1 in the expression of food-entrainable circadian rhythms in rodents.

    Original languageEnglish
    Article number3
    JournalJournal of Circadian Rhythms
    Volume7
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2009 Mar 26

    Fingerprint

    Hypothalamus
    Mediodorsal Thalamic Nucleus
    Food
    Circadian Clocks
    Circadian Rhythm
    Suprachiasmatic Nucleus
    Manuscripts
    Rodentia
    Appointments and Schedules
    Light
    Mutation
    Genes

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Physiology
    • Endocrine and Autonomic Systems

    Cite this

    Standards of evidence in chronobiology : Critical review of a report that restoration of Bmal1 expression in the dorsomedial hypothalamus is sufficient to restore circadian food anticipatory rhythms in Bmal1-/- mice. / Mistlberger, Ralph E.; Buijs, Ruud M.; Challet, Etienne; Escobar, Carolina; Landry, Glenn J.; Kalsbeek, Andries; Pevet, Paul; Shibata, Shigenobu.

    In: Journal of Circadian Rhythms, Vol. 7, 3, 26.03.2009.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    @article{006e60c1e6594f61a0259ec6b28b3248,
    title = "Standards of evidence in chronobiology: Critical review of a report that restoration of Bmal1 expression in the dorsomedial hypothalamus is sufficient to restore circadian food anticipatory rhythms in Bmal1-/- mice",
    abstract = "Daily feeding schedules generate food anticipatory rhythms of behavior and physiology that exhibit canonical properties of circadian clock control. The molecular mechanisms and location of food-entrainable circadian oscillators hypothesized to control food anticipatory rhythms are unknown. In 2008, Fuller et al reported that food-entrainable circadian rhythms are absent in mice bearing a null mutation of the circadian clock gene Bmal1 and that these rhythms can be rescued by virally-mediated restoration of Bmal1 expression in the dorsomedial nucleus of the hypothalamus (DMH) but not in the suprachiasmatic nucleus (site of the master light-entrainable circadian pacemaker). These results, taken together with controversial DMH lesion results published by the same laboratory, appear to establish the DMH as the site of a Bmal1-dependent circadian mechanism necessary and sufficient for food anticipatory rhythms. However, careful examination of the manuscript reveals numerous weaknesses in the evidence as presented. These problems are grouped as follows and elaborated in detail: 1. data management issues (apparent misalignments of plotted data), 2. failure of evidence to support the major conclusions, and 3. missing data and methodological details. The Fuller et al results are therefore considered inconclusive, and fail to clarify the role of either the DMH or Bmal1 in the expression of food-entrainable circadian rhythms in rodents.",
    author = "Mistlberger, {Ralph E.} and Buijs, {Ruud M.} and Etienne Challet and Carolina Escobar and Landry, {Glenn J.} and Andries Kalsbeek and Paul Pevet and Shigenobu Shibata",
    year = "2009",
    month = "3",
    day = "26",
    doi = "10.1186/1740-3391-7-3",
    language = "English",
    volume = "7",
    journal = "Journal of Circadian Rhythms",
    issn = "1740-3391",
    publisher = "BioMed Central",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Standards of evidence in chronobiology

    T2 - Critical review of a report that restoration of Bmal1 expression in the dorsomedial hypothalamus is sufficient to restore circadian food anticipatory rhythms in Bmal1-/- mice

    AU - Mistlberger, Ralph E.

    AU - Buijs, Ruud M.

    AU - Challet, Etienne

    AU - Escobar, Carolina

    AU - Landry, Glenn J.

    AU - Kalsbeek, Andries

    AU - Pevet, Paul

    AU - Shibata, Shigenobu

    PY - 2009/3/26

    Y1 - 2009/3/26

    N2 - Daily feeding schedules generate food anticipatory rhythms of behavior and physiology that exhibit canonical properties of circadian clock control. The molecular mechanisms and location of food-entrainable circadian oscillators hypothesized to control food anticipatory rhythms are unknown. In 2008, Fuller et al reported that food-entrainable circadian rhythms are absent in mice bearing a null mutation of the circadian clock gene Bmal1 and that these rhythms can be rescued by virally-mediated restoration of Bmal1 expression in the dorsomedial nucleus of the hypothalamus (DMH) but not in the suprachiasmatic nucleus (site of the master light-entrainable circadian pacemaker). These results, taken together with controversial DMH lesion results published by the same laboratory, appear to establish the DMH as the site of a Bmal1-dependent circadian mechanism necessary and sufficient for food anticipatory rhythms. However, careful examination of the manuscript reveals numerous weaknesses in the evidence as presented. These problems are grouped as follows and elaborated in detail: 1. data management issues (apparent misalignments of plotted data), 2. failure of evidence to support the major conclusions, and 3. missing data and methodological details. The Fuller et al results are therefore considered inconclusive, and fail to clarify the role of either the DMH or Bmal1 in the expression of food-entrainable circadian rhythms in rodents.

    AB - Daily feeding schedules generate food anticipatory rhythms of behavior and physiology that exhibit canonical properties of circadian clock control. The molecular mechanisms and location of food-entrainable circadian oscillators hypothesized to control food anticipatory rhythms are unknown. In 2008, Fuller et al reported that food-entrainable circadian rhythms are absent in mice bearing a null mutation of the circadian clock gene Bmal1 and that these rhythms can be rescued by virally-mediated restoration of Bmal1 expression in the dorsomedial nucleus of the hypothalamus (DMH) but not in the suprachiasmatic nucleus (site of the master light-entrainable circadian pacemaker). These results, taken together with controversial DMH lesion results published by the same laboratory, appear to establish the DMH as the site of a Bmal1-dependent circadian mechanism necessary and sufficient for food anticipatory rhythms. However, careful examination of the manuscript reveals numerous weaknesses in the evidence as presented. These problems are grouped as follows and elaborated in detail: 1. data management issues (apparent misalignments of plotted data), 2. failure of evidence to support the major conclusions, and 3. missing data and methodological details. The Fuller et al results are therefore considered inconclusive, and fail to clarify the role of either the DMH or Bmal1 in the expression of food-entrainable circadian rhythms in rodents.

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=64049092743&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=64049092743&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1186/1740-3391-7-3

    DO - 10.1186/1740-3391-7-3

    M3 - Article

    C2 - 19323828

    AN - SCOPUS:64049092743

    VL - 7

    JO - Journal of Circadian Rhythms

    JF - Journal of Circadian Rhythms

    SN - 1740-3391

    M1 - 3

    ER -